The Inside Assyria Discussion Forum #5

=> an email exchange between me and the fellow who was aghast at belly dancing

an email exchange between me and the fellow who was aghast at belly dancing
Posted by pancho (Moderator) - Saturday, February 25 2012, 0:31:35 (UTC)
from *** - *** Mexico - Windows XP - Mozilla
Website:
Website title:

...my email to him....


...I was scrolling through the message board at aina, the black eye of assyria, when I came across a post regarding belly dancing and how awful it is for assyrians to have anything to do with it, signed "marodeen, the Gatekeeper", I am assuming that is you...that wasn't the part that caught my eye...what I want to ask you is where you get your information that Arabs have been killing us for centuries and forcing us to convert to Islam...I ask you this in hopes that you might actually have some actual facts and instances because I have issued this challenge to many of our assyrian nationalists and so far, after four years, not one of them has produced a single instance, though they still repeat it every chance they get....so, if you have any actual historical evidence to back this up I would be most eager to see it....what I specifically want to know, because this is implied in your post, is instances when Arabs have killed us JUST because of our religion, or tried to forcibly convert us on pain of death....tankis.


...his reply,


I think you like to read http://www.aina.org/books/stnd.htm
by the way I think you don't watch any news about Christian in the middle East on TV they love us in there that is way every one trying to get out why don't you go there and a buy a house and live there too
it looks like getting old is starting effect your brain.

...the whole dreary series of replies to honest questions after facts....

a. "can't you see Christians getting killed"?

b. you don;t "watch the news" and are therefor ignorant...when all I asked for was evidence.

c. and, why don;t I go live there since I think it's so safe and nice and welcoming.

But...no sources, except that same ridiculous one they all use; aina, of all places. But nothing else, nothing more...not even a single instance, which he could have gotten from aina hisself, if this is so true and accurate...except he knows what will be done with any "facts" from aina.


...my reply,

...Look, I'm treating you as an adult...I never said Muslims haven't killed Christians....I also know that millions of Christians have killed other Christians...you may have heard of WW I...and the Religious Wars of Europe where Christian slaughtered Christians etc...so let's not change the subject just to play stupid...you claim that Islam and Muslims killed us JUST because we are Christians...and I want evidence for that and I'm sorry but aina and what it puts up is not evidence accepted anywhere..I mean as recorded by qualified historians of which there are hundreds who are all Christian who say this never happened...the other thing I asked you for was evidence that Muslims massacred us when we refused to convert to Islam...I realize you believe all this but what I'm asking you for is EVIDENCE from RELIABLE sources who are accepted and believed by the real world and not just us...can you provide anything like that...yes or no....and never mind telling me where to go live...I live where I want, that has nothing to do with the issue at hand, which is the reliability and honesty and verifiability of your claims.....tankis


...not surprisingly....silence. This is not the way people behave who actually DO have believable evidence...if there was any he would RUSH to get it to me.



---------------------


The full topic:



***



Powered by RedKernel V.S. Forum 1.2.b9